Second Avenue Mansions of Yesteryear

Woah! Can you believe the corner of St. Marks Place and Second Avenue once looked like this?

1903 photo of the mansion, courtesy Museum of the City of New York

Our survey of the history of every single building in the East Village has turned up photos of some of the mansions that once lined Second Avenue – the neighborhood’s prime residential thoroughfare in the first half of the 19th century.

Though most famous as a hotspot for counterculture, St. Marks Place was one of the most elite streets in the entire city when it was first built up in the 1830s by developer Thomas E. Davis. Davis built this mansion at the corner of Second Avenue in 1836. It was purchased a decade later by Eugene Keteltas, and remained in the Keteltas family for the rest of its life. Eugene’s daughter Alice was its last resident; she lived there for 70 years before moving to Fifth Avenue & 79th street in 1912. That same year, a permit was filed to replace the mansion with a movie theater. Newspaper articles claim that the before its destruction, the mansion was the last remaining grand private dwelling in the neighborhood, and the final holdout from Second Avenue’s original glory days.

The 1912 building that housed the theater still stands today:

The Keteltas mansion was replaced with a movie theater in 1913

Here’s a view of the mansion from Second Avenue:

The Keteltas mansion from Second Avenue in ca. 1899, courtesy Museum of the City of NY|

And along St. Mark’s Place, as it was being demolished:

The Keteltas mansion undergoing demolition in 1913, courtesy NYPL

Just up the Avenue was another beautiful mansion. At the northwest corner of East 11th Street stood the Rutherford mansion, built for Peter Gerard Stuyvesant in 1845. Stuyvesant died unexpectedly only two years later, after which the home was given to Stuyvesant Rutherford (son of the renowned scientist Dr. Lewis Morris Rutherford) on the grounds that his name be changed to Rutherford Stuyvesant (is was). Rutherford then deeded the house to his father, who built an observatory in the yard from which he took his groundbreaking photographs of the sun, moon & stars.

The Rutherford mansion in 1922, courtesy New York Public Library

In 1885, the house was converted to apartments, and in 1915 was acquired by St. Mark’s Hospital. It was finally replaced in 1935 with the six-story apartment building that stands on the site today.

The same view today

Which takes us to the third and final mansion we’ll visit in this post. On the east side of Second Avenue between 9th & 10th Streets stood the Ransom House, which a 1937 New Yorker article claimed was occupied by relatives of the Astors.

156 Second Avenue in ca. 1899, courtesy Museum of the City of New York

The mansion later became Cafe Boulevard, a famed Hungarian restaurant and chess room. In 1900, the New York Times proclaimed Second Avenue from Houston to East 10th Street “The Hungarian Broadway” for the sheer preponderance of Hungarian restaurants to be found there.

Cafe Boulevard, courtesy Museum of the City of New York

It was finally sold and demolished in 1915, and replaced with the apartment building that occupies the site today and houses Chase Bank (formerly the Second Avenue Deli).

The 1915 apartment building that still occupies the site today

If you’re interested in learning more about our work in the East Village, visit our East Village Preservation page!


Read other posts by

avatar Elizabeth Finkelstein is GVSHP's Director of Preservation & Research.